Cap Anson – 1987 Old Judge
By far, this Cap Anson is the oldest on this list and has been pulled from the 1887 Old Judge collection. To date, many legends who have made their name from playing the game and those who deem themselves true fans have classified this Anson card as the oldest with the most value from its time. This particular card depicting him in his costume is the gem among the pack as it is the priciest and most rarely printed. It could give you some extra cash should you have one to trade.
Jackie Robinson – 1948 Leaf
Jackie Robinson’s name will never be out of the history books for baseball lovers around the world. Robinson made his debut during the 1900s and broke the barrier in racial views for the sport. Having one of his cards is a rare gem and is often sought after by the deepest fans and enthusiasts worldwide. It is among the rarest prints of the 50s, and should you own it, you could be sitting on roughly $75,000.